By Martha Friendly, Executive Director, Childcare Resource and Research Unit, and
Gordon Cleveland, Associate Professor of Economics Emeritus, University of Toronto Scarborough
- Many more children are in licensed child care (especially centres) now than before the $10-a-day program
In 2023, 177,900 more 0-5 year olds were reported by Statistics Canada to be in child care centres than at the end of 2020 just before the $10-a-day program began.
- Nearly a million Canadian 0-5 year olds already benefit from low-fee licensed child care
938,000 children are using licensed child care that is eligible for the $10 a day program, according to 2023 Statistics Canada. If we add four and five year olds in kindergarten, and children at home with parents on parental leave, a total of 1.5 million young children are benefitting from public programs that support the care of young children as well as mothers’ employment and family incomes.
- There is considerably more licensed child care than ever before
Between 2015 and 2023, the number of child care spaces for children 0-12 grew by 426,203 to a total of more than 1.6 million licensed spaces, despite the negative effects of the pandemic on child care services and mothers’ employment.
- For the first time ever, child care has been made affordable for parents across the income spectrum
In eight provinces and territories (including Quebec), parents now pay $10-a-day or less for licensed child care. In the other jurisdictions, fees have been substantially reduced by provincial/territorial fee reduction or are provincially set. The fee changes mean that parent fees are between one-sixth to one-third of the fees before the $10-a-day program, depending on the province/territory. In addition, all provinces and territories except Alberta have fee subsidy programs to lower child care fees further for parents with particularly low incomes.
- Waitlists for licensed child care were always long but have grown
Although nearly a million Canadian children are benefiting from low-fee child care, there are too few licensed spaces and many families are still on waiting lists. Nearly 50% of child care users reported difficulty finding a space in 2023— about 10% more than the nearly 40% reporting difficulty finding care in 2020 before the CWELCC program began.
Many employed families who use other child care arrangements can claim financial assistance from the Child Care Expense Deduction, and most families with young children also receive the Canada Child Benefit – income support to help families with child rearing costs.
There is good agreement that provinces and territories must speed up expansion of spaces and hiring of qualified staff to reduce waitlists. To support this, federal government has made $625 million for child care infrastructure available to provinces and territories and allocated $1 billion of low-interest loans and grants for child care expansion to be distributed by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
- The $10-a-day child care program is very popular with parents, so demand for licensed child care, especially centres, is high.
Already in 2023, three-quarters of children in any form of non-parental child care were in licensed child care. On top of this, a majority of those not currently using any non-parental child care said they would like to use it too. Of these, 62% would prefer to use a child care centre.
- For-profit providers are not being driven out of business
Mr. Poilievre claims that for-profit child care providers are being driven out of business. Agreements signed between the federal government and the provinces and territories included all existing child care providers willing to lower parent fees and provide accountability in exchange for very substantial, reliable public funding.
For-profit providers unwilling to participate in the low-fee program may set their own fees instead of relying on government funding. The agreements with provinces and territories specify that new spaces should be primarily in not-for-profit or public centres or in licensed family child care homes. This protective provision is intended to ensure that higher profits should not be the predominant rationale of a system of publicly funded services for children and families.
- Pierre Poilievre’s “freedom and flexibility” child care policy would raise child care fees
Opponents of publicly funded universal child care claim that the $10-a-day plan is a bad idea—“a massive top-down bureaucratic system”, “one-size-fits-all”, and “worse today than when the Liberals took office”, arguing instead for payments to parents. Pierre Poilievre’s alternative is “more flexibility and freedom for parents, provinces, and providers”.
In other words, Mr. Poilievre’s alternative would allow provinces to eliminate the $10 a day program. Instead, providers will have the flexibility and freedom to set their own parent fees, and provinces will have the flexibility and freedom to use federal funds to support unregulated child care or favour for-profit operations. Slashing red tape will mean child care providers will no longer need to account for how they spend billions of dollars of funding.
Mr. Poilievre’s alternative is to go back to the previous scarce-space, high-fee, market-model child care. This didn’t work during the nine years in which the Harper government (of which Mr. Poilievre was a member) tried out its market model, and it won’t work now.
April 14, 2025